Talk:Cutter Types (Lathe)

OWNER: Gatl2189 (talk) 21:22, 27 May 2013 (UTC)

Mentor Comments from 5/30/13

 * Should have description in first section (with table of contents) like all Wikipedia pages
 * For Overview
 * No apostrophe in the word numbers (plural not possessive)
 * Fix weird box in Tooling section
 * Consistent capitalization
 * Consider changing name of Tooling to "Cutter classification"
 * No comma after two in "More types of tools"
 * Use consistent language in description column
 * Condense information into 1 or at max 2 pictures with a textual description. I don't think a table is necessary here
 * Common Lathe Cutting Tool Types
 * Consider changing name of "Facing tool" to "Facing/turning tool"
 * Consider changing name of "Boring tool" to "Boring bar"
 * Tool Speeds

Add section(or include in Tool Speeds) for identifying carbide vs high speed steel cutters. It seems like some of the material is repeated several times. It is better to condense information and not repeat. Include a general description (text) in the first section. Try to make all of the descriptions use consistent format (all sentences or all short comments).

Overall good start. Keep up the good work and this page will be very useful for future students.

Bowe6786 (talk) 18:19, 30 May 2013 (UTC)

Mentor Comments from 5/28/13

 * Description:
 * See Developers' Bulletin for proper formatting and content
 * Consider have a quick overview of the tools such as Manual_Lathe
 * Lathe Cutting Tool Types
 * Consider section title change to Detailed description of tools
 * Use Item/Setup table: Developers' Bulletin
 * Pictures
 * Make sure the follow the guidelines found here: Developers' Bulletin
 * Make sure they are the correct orientation.

The above contents are mainly for formating, I will check content Wednesday. From a quick glance, the content looks mostly complete, but make sure to check with other sources such as the machinist book, McMaster, wikipedia, etc for a second check. Also, remove 'This is the...' as the name of the tool will be included image caption

Alex7832 (talk) 04:41, 29 May 2013 (UTC)